Analysis
How Liberal Democracy Can Survive an Age of Spiraling Crises: A Conversation With Daron Acemoglu
The 2024 Nobel laureate explains why democracy’s survival depends on working-class prosperity—and what happens when institutions fail to deliver
When only 28% of Americans express satisfaction with how their democracy functions—a historic low recorded in January 2024—the warning signals are impossible to ignore. This isn’t merely a statistical artifact of partisan frustration. It represents something more fundamental: a crisis of delivery, where democratic institutions have systematically failed to fulfill their core promises to ordinary citizens.
Daron Acemoglu, the MIT economist who received the 2024 Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences, argues that liberal democracy flourished when it pursued its core promises of shared prosperity, democratic governance at the local and national level, and the free pursuit of knowledge. But those promises now ring hollow for millions who have watched inequality skyrocket while their own economic prospects stagnate. The question facing advanced democracies isn’t whether they’re under threat—the data confirms they are—but whether they possess the institutional capacity to reform themselves before it’s too late.
Table of Contents
The Polycrisis: When Multiple Failures Converge
We live in what scholars call a “polycrisis”—a condition where multiple, overlapping emergencies compound one another in ways that transcend their individual impacts. The numbers tell a stark story: between 2016 and 2024, the number of people living with democratic rights fell from 3.9 billion to 2.3 billion. This isn’t gradual erosion; it’s a democratic recession affecting nearly 1.6 billion people in less than a decade.
The Varieties of Democracy (V-Dem) Institute documents this retreat with precision. As of 2024, 42 countries are experiencing ongoing episodes of autocratization, a process where elected leaders systematically dismantle the very institutions that brought them to power. What makes this wave particularly insidious is its legalistic veneer—authoritarianism advancing through the ballot box rather than military coups.
But the democratic crisis doesn’t exist in isolation. It intersects with economic turbulence that has reshaped the social contract across industrialized nations. Consider the wealth concentration dynamics: In the United States, households in the top 10% of the wealth distribution own more than half—specifically 52%—of all total household wealth, with this share reaching as high as 79%. Meanwhile, income inequality measured by the Gini coefficient varies dramatically across OECD countries, ranging from approximately 0.22 in the Slovak Republic to more than double that in Chile, Costa Rica, and the United States.
This economic bifurcation creates what Acemoglu calls the preconditions for democratic decay. When democracy stops delivering shared prosperity, citizens begin questioning whether democratic institutions serve their interests at all.
Acemoglu’s Diagnostic: The Narrow Corridor and Institutional Balance
To understand how democracies survive—or fail—Acemoglu and his longtime collaborator James Robinson developed what they term “the narrow corridor” theory. The concept, detailed in their 2019 book of the same name, rejects the notion that liberty emerges naturally from either strong states or weak ones. Instead, freedom arises from a delicate balance between state power and an empowered society, where institutions provide education, healthcare, infrastructure, and protection from violence while remaining constrained enough that they cannot become predatory.
This framework helps explain puzzling variations in democratic outcomes. Why did some countries successfully democratize while others with similar initial conditions descended into autocracy or chaos? The answer lies in institutional design and the continuous tension between state capacity and societal mobilization.
Acemoglu’s research with Robinson and others has found that democracy directly contributes to economic growth, though it takes time—countries that democratize generally grow faster and invest more in education and health. But this relationship isn’t automatic. It depends on whether democratic institutions remain genuinely inclusive or become captured by narrow elites.
The extractive-versus-inclusive framework provides the analytical foundation. Extractive institutions concentrate power and wealth in the hands of a small elite, extracting resources from the broader population. Inclusive institutions, by contrast, distribute political power widely and create incentives for education, innovation, and broad-based economic participation.
History offers abundant examples. For three decades following World War II, democracy delivered shared prosperity as real (inflation-adjusted) wages increased rapidly for all demographic groups and inequality declined, but this trend ended in the late 1970s and early 1980s. Since then, the compact has broken down. Wages for workers without college degrees have stagnated while inequality has exploded—creating precisely the conditions under which populist demagogues thrive.
Economic Foundations of Democratic Fragility
The connection between economic inequality and democratic backsliding isn’t merely correlational. It operates through specific mechanisms that Acemoglu has spent decades documenting.
Democracy is in crisis throughout the industrialized world because its performance has fallen short of what was promised, with far-right and extremist parties benefiting from the fact that center-left and center-right parties are associated with wage stagnation, rising inequality, and other unfavorable trends. This isn’t hyperbole—it’s observable reality across Europe and North America.
The wealth inequality data reveals the scale of the problem. Brazil, Russia, and South Africa top global rankings for wealth inequality, each posting Gini coefficients around the low 0.8s on a scale where 0 represents perfect equality and 1 represents maximum inequality. But even wealthy democracies show troubling patterns. Among OECD countries in 2021, the ratio of average income between the richest 10% and poorest 10% of the population was 8.4 to 1.
These disparities matter because they shape political behavior. More than 60% of respondents across surveyed countries declared that disparities in income and wealth were too high or far too high in their country. When large swaths of the population feel economically abandoned, they become receptive to politicians promising to overturn the existing system—democratic norms be damned.
Acemoglu’s recent work emphasizes how technological change amplifies these dynamics. Automation and artificial intelligence threaten to further concentrate wealth and eliminate middle-skill jobs, precisely the economic foundation that historically sustained democratic stability. Without deliberate policy interventions to ensure technology creates broadly shared prosperity rather than extracting value for a narrow class of owners and investors, the economic pressure on democracy will only intensify.
The Polarization Multiplier
Economic anxiety doesn’t operate in a vacuum—it interacts with political polarization to create a toxic feedback loop threatening democratic stability.
In spring 2024, only 22% of U.S. adults said they trust the federal government to do the right thing just about always or most of the time, up slightly from the previous year’s historic low of 16%. This institutional mistrust reflects and reinforces partisan divisions. The Centers for Disease Control, for instance, received a 78% favorable rating among Democrats but only 33% approval from Republicans in 2024—a 45-percentage point chasm reflecting not scientific evidence but tribal identity.
The share of Americans who consider themselves on the far left or far right of the political spectrum is particularly high in the United States, with 11% placing themselves on the far left and 19% on the far right. Compare this to Germany, where only 6% identify as far left and 7% as far right, and the distinctive character of American polarization becomes clear.
This affective polarization—the emotional hostility between political tribes—proves more destabilizing than mere policy disagreements. Research shows it enables voters to excuse antidemocratic behavior by their own side while viewing identical actions by opponents as existential threats. Three-quarters of Americans said in 2023 that the future of American democracy was at risk in the 2024 presidential election, with both sides viewing the other as the primary threat.
The international context provides little comfort. Since 2000, 45 countries have experienced significant decline in the free and fair nature of their elections, relating to the spread of misinformation, interference from foreign actors, and erosion of public trust. These trends aren’t unique to any single nation—they represent a global pattern threatening the third wave of democratization.
Institutional Resilience: Pathways Forward
Despite documenting democracy’s current travails, Acemoglu’s analysis isn’t fundamentally pessimistic. The narrow corridor framework suggests that democratic renewal remains possible—but only through specific institutional reforms and renewed social mobilization.
Democracy has long promised four things: shared prosperity, a voice for the citizenry, expertise-driven governance, and effective public services. Rebuilding these pillars requires concrete policy changes, not merely rhetorical commitments.
First, the economic compact must be restored. This means policies explicitly designed to ensure technology creates good jobs rather than merely automating existing ones. Acemoglu and co-author Simon Johnson argue in their recent work that AI deployment should be shaped by tax policy, regulation, and public investment to favor labor-augmenting rather than labor-replacing technologies.
Second, political institutions need structural reforms to rebuild representativeness. This includes addressing gerrymandering, campaign finance distortions, and the ways money translates directly into political power—all of which allow narrow interests to capture democratic processes.
Third, strengthening the civic infrastructure that enables ordinary citizens to organize, deliberate, and hold power accountable. Some countries like Austria, Chile, Nepal, and South Africa faced early warning signs of deterioration but demonstrated onset resilience to autocratization, providing examples of how mobilized societies can push back against democratic backsliding.
The comparative evidence suggests these interventions work. Countries that have successfully reversed democratic decline share common features: active civil society, reformed electoral systems, and economic policies that deliver tangible improvements in living standards for working families.
The Working-Class Imperative
Perhaps Acemoglu’s most urgent recent argument concerns democracy’s relationship with working-class voters—the constituencies that democratic institutions were originally designed to empower.
While Democrats have won recent elections with support from Silicon Valley, minorities, trade unions, and professionals in large cities, this coalition was never sustainable because the party became culturally disconnected from, and disdainful of, precisely the voters it needs to win. This diagnosis applies beyond American politics to center-left parties across the industrialized world.
The policy implications are clear: More good jobs—finding ways to create good jobs in communities and spreading prosperity that way—must become the organizing principle of democratic governance. This isn’t about nostalgia for manufacturing employment but about ensuring that economic growth translates into broadly shared gains rather than concentrated windfalls for asset owners.
Historical precedent supports this emphasis. The golden age of democratic stability in advanced economies—roughly 1945 to 1980—corresponded precisely to the period when working-class incomes grew fastest. Democracy thrived when it delivered economic security. It now struggles because that delivery system has broken down.
Technology, AI, and Democratic Futures
The technological landscape adds new complexity to democracy’s challenges. Artificial intelligence, in particular, presents both opportunities and acute risks for democratic governance.
On one hand, AI could enhance state capacity, improve public service delivery, and accelerate scientific progress in ways that benefit everyone. On the other, it threatens to concentrate economic power even further, eliminate millions of middle-skill jobs, enable unprecedented surveillance, and flood information ecosystems with AI-generated propaganda.
Acemoglu has testified before the U.S. Senate warning that AI deployment, if left to pure market forces, will likely accelerate inequality and undermine social cohesion. The technology itself is neutral, but its institutional context determines whether it strengthens or erodes democracy. Companies designing AI systems for automation rather than augmentation—replacing human judgment rather than enhancing it—make choices that ripple through the entire political economy.
The policy challenge involves steering technology toward inclusive outcomes without stifling innovation. This requires active industrial policy, thoughtful regulation, and potentially significant changes to how we tax capital versus labor. None of this is simple, but the alternative—allowing technological change to further hollow out the economic middle class—represents a clear pathway to democratic collapse.
Can Democracy Deliver Again?
The central question isn’t whether democracy faces a crisis—democracy is going through a very, very tough stretch, in part because it has not realized its promise for all people, particularly those at the lower end of the labor market. The question is whether democratic systems retain sufficient institutional capacity to reform themselves.
Acemoglu’s framework suggests cautious optimism grounded in historical realism. Democracies have weathered serious challenges before—the Great Depression, World War II, the civil rights struggles. Each time, reform came not from benevolent elites but from mobilized citizens demanding that institutions live up to their stated values.
The narrow corridor theory reminds us that democratic liberty has never been the default state. It emerges only from continuous struggle—the Red Queen effect, where state and society must keep running just to stay in place. Complacency leads to drift toward either despotism or anarchy.
Current global trends provide both warning and possibility. In Thailand, Zambia, and other nations, democracy eroded but people resisted growing authoritarianism, allowing these countries to partially or fully restore previous levels of liberal democracy. These reversals demonstrate that when democracy deteriorates, its fate isn’t sealed—institutions can be reclaimed through organized citizen action.
The Stakes: Liberty and Prosperity
The conversation with Acemoglu ultimately centers on what we risk losing. Democracy isn’t merely a set of procedures for selecting leaders—it’s the institutional foundation for both human liberty and shared prosperity.
It’s very difficult to maintain economic inclusion when ruled by the iron fist of an autocrat, Acemoglu notes. The extractive institutions that characterize autocracies systematically prevent the broad-based innovation, education, and entrepreneurship that drive sustained economic growth.
The stakes extend beyond economics to human dignity and freedom. Autocratic alternatives promise efficiency and decisive action, but they deliver neither. Instead, they concentrate power in ways that ultimately serve narrow interests while suppressing the very social dynamism that makes societies vibrant and productive.
For liberal democracy to survive this age of spiraling crises, it must rediscover its core promise: building inclusive institutions that genuinely serve the broad public rather than narrow elites. This requires confronting economic inequality, repairing social trust, reforming broken political systems, and ensuring that technological change serves human flourishing rather than extractive concentration.
The narrow corridor ahead is treacherous. But it remains navigable—if we choose to walk it with clear eyes and determined purpose.
About the Research
This analysis draws on Daron Acemoglu’s extensive body of work, including “Why Nations Fail” (2012) with James Robinson, “The Narrow Corridor” (2019), and his recent Project Syndicate commentaries on democratic crisis and working-class politics. Data sources include the Varieties of Democracy (V-Dem) Institute, OECD inequality statistics, Pew Research Center political surveys, and World Bank inequality metrics.
Discover more from The Monitor
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
AI
Nvidia Shockwave: Why Your 401(k) is More Exposed to the Chip Giant
Recent market turbulence centered around artificial intelligence bellwether Nvidia (NASDAQ: NVDA) has sent shockwaves across Wall Street, triggered by a steep correction following the sudden resignation of longtime CEO Jensen Huang.
For everyday savers who believe they are safe because they do not own a single individual share of tech stocks, the reality is starkly different. Due to Nvidia’s massive weight in major equity indices, millions of Americans watching their retirement accounts fluctuate are experiencing a hard lesson in concentration risk.
1. The S&P 500 and Nasdaq Concentration Problem
Over the past several years, the explosive growth of generative AI transformed Nvidia into a titan of the global economy, commanding a market capitalization that pushed its weighting in major capitalization-weighted indexes to historic highs:
- S&P 500 Exposure: Nvidia commands roughly 6% to 8% of standard S&P 500 index funds (such as SPY or VOO).
- Tech-Heavy & Growth Funds: In specialized tech-heavy or growth-oriented ETFs (like the Invesco QQQ tracking the Nasdaq-100), Nvidia’s exposure routinely scales past 6.5% to 25% depending on the specific mandate.
The Math Behind the 401(k) Hit
When a mega-cap stock experiences a sharp ~30% correction over a single month—compounded by sudden leadership turmoil and board investigations—the math hits passive retirement portfolios hard:
- For every $100,000 allocated to a standard S&P 500 index fund, a 30% drop in Nvidia accounts for an approximate $2,400 reduction in underlying value (assuming other index components remain flat).
- For a typical Baby Boomer with an average 401(k) balance near $260,000 heavily weighted toward growth or index-tracking tech portfolios, the structural reduction can easily translate to a $15,000 to $20,000 paper loss.
2. The Illusion of Diversification: Overlap Risk
Many retirement investors assume that holding multiple funds guarantees safety. However, modern 401(k) lineups often suffer from hidden overlap risk.
An investor holding a mix of a broad S&P 500 fund, a Nasdaq-100 growth fund (QQQ), a technology sector ETF (XLK), and a semiconductor index (SMH) may believe they are diversifying across different vehicles. In reality, they are often doubling and tripling down on the exact same underlying asset. When a shock hits Nvidia, multiple pillars of their portfolio fracture simultaneously.
3. Strategic Action Plan for 401(k) Investors
Market corrections triggered by corporate governance shocks or executive departures serve as vital stress-tests for personal wealth plans. Financial professionals recommend taking the following proactive steps:
+---------------------------------------------------------------+
| 401(k) RISK MITIGATION CHECKLIST |
+---------------------------------------------------------------+
| [ ] 1. Audit Underlying Holdings: Look past fund names |
| to check top-10 equity weightings. |
| [ ] 2. Evaluate Overlap: Identify if multiple funds |
| duplicate mega-cap tech exposure. |
| [ ] 3. Consider Equal-Weight Alternatives: Explore equal- |
| weighted indexes (e.g., RSP) to reduce single-stock |
| dominance. |
| [ ] 4. Rebalance with Discipline: Align asset allocation |
| with your actual risk tolerance, not recent hype. |
+---------------------------------------------------------------+
- Conduct a Portfolio X-Ray: Use retirement platform tools to look past fund labels and analyze your true aggregate exposure to top-tier mega-cap stocks.
- Explore Equal-Weight Alternatives: For investors concerned about market cap concentration, shifting a portion of equity allocation to equal-weighted indexes (such as the Invesco S&P 500 Equal Weight ETF) ensures that a single corporate event cannot disproportionately sway total returns.
- Remember the Golden Rule of Volatility: Paper losses in a long-term retirement vehicle do not crystallize unless positions are sold during a panic. Time horizon and disciplined asset allocation remain the ultimate safeguards against single-stock volatility.
Discover more from The Monitor
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Analysis
The First Muslim Senator and the Limits of America’s Midterm Revolt
Can the new Congress challenge Trump’s immigration crackdown—or will election-night history meet the hard limits of presidential power?

On election night in Michigan, Abdul El-Sayed did more than hold a Senate seat for the Democrats. A 42-year-old physician and former public-health official, the American-born son of Egyptian immigrants became, according to media projections, the first Muslim ever elected to the United States Senate. The Republican he defeated, former congressman Mike Rogers, had questioned his political associations through allegations of extremist sympathies that El-Sayed denied and that Reuters reported were unsupported by evidence.
The result carried unmistakable symbolic weight. After months in which arguments about national identity and immigration enforcement filled American politics, a Muslim candidate won statewide office in a battleground that had twice supported Donald Trump for president. With about 97% of votes counted, El-Sayed led by seven percentage points, the Associated Press reported. Those are preliminary returns, not a certified final margin.
Yet the hardest question begins where the celebration ends. Can a senator-elect, even one whose victory expands the boundaries of political representation, alter the federal machinery that determines whether migrants are detained, deported, given a hearing—or returned to families? Or will the Democratic takeover of Congress produce televised confrontations while immigration agents continue to operate under presidential direction?
The midterms answered one question decisively: control of Congress can change. Whether the treatment of immigrants changes with it is a much more demanding test.
A breakthrough—though not a wave of immigrant-born senators
The distinction matters from the outset. El-Sayed is not an immigrant; he was born in Michigan to Egyptian immigrant parents. His win is a milestone for Muslim representation and for the children of immigrants, not evidence that large numbers of foreign-born candidates captured Senate seats. Reuters’ account of the reaction in Egypt illuminates both the significance of his heritage and the awkwardness of treating an American election as a victory belonging to another nation.
El-Sayed’s biography resists a single-issue reading. He trained as a physician, led Detroit’s health department, lost a Democratic gubernatorial primary in 2018, and returned with a campaign centered on affordability, corporate influence and Medicare for All. His opposition to unconditional American military support for Israel drew intense scrutiny; his Republican opponent argued that his views were too radical. CBS News’ examination of the campaign and the Associated Press’ post-election interview show a candidate who won by emphasizing economic discontent while also confronting attacks on his religion.
A candidate’s identity does not establish his entire agenda. On immigration, however, El-Sayed has made specific commitments. In an October interview with Michigan Public, he supported border security but called for abolishing ICE and replacing its approach with an enforcement and administrative system closer to the former Immigration and Naturalization Service. He criticized operations involving masked officers and argued that Congress had relinquished too much of its constitutional authority. His position is more sweeping than a demand for better body cameras or disciplinary proceedings: it would require Congress to redesign a federal agency.
The wider Senate class reveals a different pattern: an enlargement of political backgrounds, not a homogeneous immigrant caucus.
| Senator-elect | State | Verified political significance | Connection to immigration debate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abdul El-Sayed (D) | Michigan | First Muslim elected to the Senate; U.S.-born son of Egyptian immigrants | Has called for replacing ICE and reforming immigration law |
| Peggy Flanagan (D) | Minnesota | First Native American woman elected to the Senate; member of the White Earth Nation | Represents an Indigenous political milestone, not an immigrant background |
| Juliana Stratton (D) | Illinois | Becomes part of a historic expansion of Black women’s Senate representation | Campaigned on abolishing ICE; not presented as immigrant-born |
| James Talarico (D) | Texas | Former teacher and state lawmaker; defeated Ken Paxton | Victory included a shift among Hispanic voters; his identity should not be conflated with immigrant status |
| Adam Hamilton (D) | Kansas | Methodist pastor who defeated Republican Roger Marshall | Stressed affordability and cross-party cooperation, illustrating motives beyond immigration |
| Josh Turek (D) | Iowa | Former Paralympian and state legislator who flipped a Republican-held seat | Disability representation and economic campaigning, not an immigrant-origin claim |
These election calls are drawn from Minnesota Public Radio, Axios’ Illinois reporting, AP’s Texas account, Reuters on Kansas and AP on Iowa. These are projected results pending the normal certification process; comparable final vote margins were not available for every race at this research cutoff.
The House contributes another part of the story. Muslim candidates reported as winners include New Jersey’s Adam Hamawy and New York’s Darializa Avila Chevalier alongside returning members such as Ilhan Omar and Rashida Tlaib, according to Dawn’s November 5 overview. This is an expansion of Muslim congressional representation across chambers, not a list of new senators. Nor should Muslim identity be used as a synonym for immigration status.
What the voters rejected—and what they did not
Democrats seized control of both chambers, including unexpected Senate gains in Texas, Kansas, Iowa, South Carolina, Maine, North Carolina and Ohio. As of the morning after the election, Reuters reported at least 54 Senate seats for the Democratic side, including allies, with some races unresolved. The Washington Post’s Senate results coverage documents the breadth of the shift.
It would nevertheless be a mistake to describe this as a referendum exclusively on deportations or anti-Muslim politics. A final Reuters/Ipsos survey of 1,765 adults found that 48% of registered voters named living costs as their leading consideration, versus 26% who named democratic norms and 13% who named immigration. That was a pre-election poll, not an exit poll proving why particular people voted as they did.
The more revealing finding is that immigration enforcement generated discontent without becoming the only, or even the principal, electoral issue. AP’s national Voter Poll, covering more than 100,000 voters, found roughly six in ten Hispanic voters supporting Democratic House candidates, a significant change from the coalition that backed Trump in 2024. In Texas, about six in ten Hispanic Senate voters supported Talarico, against approximately three in ten for Paxton. These are survey estimates for specific electorates and contests, not a census of all Hispanic Americans.
Economic and political factors overlapped. The Washington Post’s analysis of its voter survey found that voters focused on immigration and crime still tended to prefer Republicans. A party can therefore lose an election without the country rejecting every element of its immigration platform. Discontent over the Iran war, gasoline prices, tariffs, health care and government accountability was also central to the result.
A further correction is essential: most immigrants cannot vote unless they have become U.S. citizens. Many Hispanic voters were born in the United States, while naturalized citizens come from every region of the world. A Congressional Research Service demographic briefing updated in September 2026 estimated 50.2 million foreign-born U.S. residents in 2024, including approximately 25.8 million naturalized citizens. Calling the midterms an “immigrant vote” without distinguishing citizenship, ancestry and ethnicity would obscure the very communities the description claims to represent.
The more defensible interpretation is that Americans assembled several forms of dissatisfaction into one electoral outcome. Identity mattered in Michigan. Enforcement tactics mattered in places touched by raids. Prices mattered almost everywhere. A national coalition won; its individual members did not necessarily vote for the same immigration reforms.
The enforcement record Congress inherits
The Trump administration’s argument is that vigorous enforcement protects public safety, restores the integrity of immigration law and deters unauthorized entry. Its supporters point to reduced unlawful border crossings and an expanded capacity to arrest and remove people subject to immigration proceedings. A pre-election AP examination of the crackdown reported both the border-security achievements claimed by the administration and the growing backlash against enforcement encounters inside American communities.
But border management and interior enforcement are distinct enterprises. The question is not simply whether a government may enforce immigration law—it may—but what procedures govern encounters, whether people can contest removal and what happens when officers make mistakes.
The restrictions extend beyond undocumented migrants. In January 2026, the administration expanded entry and visa restrictions affecting nationals of 39 countries and holders of Palestinian Authority travel documents, with category-specific exceptions. The State Department’s own guidance explains the restrictions as national-security screening. Many affected countries are Muslim-majority, but not all are; critics characterize the policy as discriminatory in design or effect. A serious legal assessment must identify the actual rule, its exceptions and the evidence for any allegation of religious discrimination rather than assume that nationality and religion are interchangeable.
Courts have not delivered a uniform verdict in immigration cases. In June, the Supreme Court rejected the administration’s broad effort to limit birthright citizenship under the Fourteenth Amendment, Reuters reported. Yet in September the same court permitted third-country deportations to resume while it considers the underlying litigation, according to Reuters. The administration argues that such transfers help remove people, including those with criminal convictions; challengers contend that migrants must be able to raise credible fears of persecution or torture before removal to an unfamiliar country. An interim court order allowing a practice to proceed is not a final determination that every application is lawful.
The consequences are immediate, not theoretical. On November 4, AP reported a federal judge’s temporary order restricting deportations of detained Afghans to Afghanistan or Pakistan after warnings about persecution risks. The case illustrates why due process has practical importance even when there is broad public support for border control: a removal decision may be irreversible long before the legal dispute is resolved.
Economic consequences also resist easy slogans. Pew Research Center estimates show that immigrants have become a substantial part of the U.S. workforce. Their participation varies across sectors and legal categories. Enforcement can reduce exploitation where unlawful employment is addressed, but indiscriminate disruptions may also impose costs on employers, workers and communities. Evaluating policy therefore requires both border and workplace data, not only arrest totals.
Three deaths, and a larger question about accountability
The killing of Lorenzo Salgado Araujo in Houston on July 7 exposes the risks of viewing every enforcement encounter solely through an immigration-status lens. The 52-year-old Mexican national was shot by an ICE officer during an attempted vehicle stop. DHS said he tried to ram an officer and that the shooting was in self-defense. His family disputed the official description. Crucially, DHS later acknowledged the officers had been seeking someone else and stopped Araujo because he resembled their target, according to AP reporting.
Agents involved were not wearing body cameras, Houston Public Media reported. Investigations were opened, and the family’s demand for an independent account remained separate from DHS’s assertion of justification. The medical examiner’s designation of a death as homicide, where applicable, is a classification of how a person died—not a criminal judgment that an officer committed murder.
Two killings in Minneapolis earlier in 2026 raised related but different questions. On January 7, ICE officer gunfire killed Renee Good, a U.S. citizen, during a vehicle encounter. Administration officials described the shooting as self-defense; AP’s examination documented video evidence, public disagreement and ongoing investigations. On January 24, federal Border Patrol agents killed Alex Pretti, also a U.S. citizen and an intensive-care nurse. The government’s initial account said he approached with a handgun; Reuters’ review of bystander video raised significant questions about the sequence of events. FactCheck.org’s analysis likewise identified claims unsupported or apparently contradicted by available footage, while warning that the investigation was incomplete.
Good and Pretti were not immigrants. Their deaths belong in this article because they arose from federal immigration operations and intensified debate about officer identification, use-of-force rules, incident reporting and independent review. Conflating their deaths with migrant fatalities would weaken the accuracy of that debate.
Deaths in detention constitute another category entirely. In June, a Reuters investigation found 50 deaths in immigration detention since January 2025 and estimated that the annualized death rate relative to the average detained population had more than doubled compared with its 2009–2024 benchmark. In September, Bloomberg Law reported 37 deaths in ICE detention during the fiscal year then ending. The figures refer to different time windows; they must not be added together.
The Department of Homeland Security has disputed claims of a rising death rate and says it maintains a high standard of medical care, as Reuters reported in June. Experts caution that illnesses, suicide, age and changing detainee populations complicate direct causal attribution. Yet complications are precisely why transparent mortality data, medical reviews and independent inspections matter. AP’s investigation into suicides in custody identified apparent shortcomings in mental-health screening and monitoring, while DHS defended its care standards.
Neither a tragic outcome nor a disputed video automatically establishes a criminal offence. Equally, invoking self-defense cannot substitute for an evidence-based investigation. The institutional question is whether investigators can obtain records, witness testimony and usable video without relying wholly on the agency whose personnel are under scrutiny.
The Senate can investigate; it cannot govern by investigation alone
The election substantially changes the machinery of oversight. Democratic chairpersons can schedule hearings, seek documents and, under committee procedures, pursue subpoenas. They can examine hiring and training standards, deaths in custody, the handling of medical emergencies, body-camera compliance, contracts with detention operators and the chain of command after fatal incidents. The Senate’s own description of investigative powers makes clear that inquiry is an established element of congressional responsibility, while its committee guidance distinguishes investigative, legislative and confirmation hearings.
Those powers are not personal prerogatives of a senator-elect. A single member can demand answers and organize public attention; enforceable congressional subpoenas ordinarily depend on authority delegated to a chamber or committee. The Justice Department’s published legal analysis makes that distinction explicit. Incoming members usually begin regular terms on January 3, 2027. They cannot simply command ICE officers in November.
The Senate can also refuse to confirm certain executive and judicial nominees, compel administration officials to defend their policies in public and consider statutory changes to detention conditions or the handling of administrative appeals. But replacing ICE, as El-Sayed advocates, would require legislation, institutional redesign, agreement over who conducts enforcement and sufficient votes. Oversight may expose violations; investigations do not themselves rewrite immigration law.
Control of both houses adds another lever: the power of the purse. There is an important catch. Congress already enacted substantial multiyear border and immigration-enforcement funding in 2026. A Congressional Research Service summary of FY2027 appropriations notes that ICE and Border Patrol continue to draw on resources from a reconciliation measure rather than relying entirely on annual appropriations. The Congressional Budget Office puts that 2026 reconciliation funding at $70 billion for those operations.
That financing limits any simple strategy of withholding next year’s regular ICE appropriation. Rescinding already enacted funds or changing the governing statutes generally requires another law, and therefore must confront the president’s signature or veto. Congress can still seek records, attach conditions to legislation that can pass, examine contracts, and make the political and administrative costs of opaque enforcement more visible.
Here the difference between protest and policy becomes evident. An investigation that identifies a broken procedure can produce a public record. A committee proposal can translate that record into a specific standard. A negotiated law can give that standard force. Each stage needs a different coalition and faces different resistance.
Trump’s veto is powerful, but it is not a universal shield
Trump has signaled that he intends to use the veto. He told CBS News in an election-day interview that it was his ultimate weapon against a Democratic Congress; after the results he publicly displayed a hat bearing the word “VETO,” as The Wall Street Journal reported.
Article I of the Constitution enables Congress to override a veto only with two-thirds of members voting in each chamber, provided a quorum is present. The Congressional Research Service’s January 2026 guide explains the mechanism. Democrats’ projected majorities are not by themselves veto-proof. Normal Senate rules, including the filibuster for most legislation, create further barriers well before a bill reaches the president’s desk.
But the veto is not authority to erase court rulings, cancel congressional investigations or prevent every request for documents. Nor does it let a president create funds that Congress has not lawfully provided. Executive discretion remains considerable, particularly over enforcement priorities and agency leadership, but it operates within statutory and constitutional limits. Court disputes may be prolonged; they are not resolved by a presidential slogan.
The next two years could therefore feature confrontation without automatic policy reversal. Hearings can focus attention on detention deaths and fatal force; judges can decide individual procedural claims; agencies can continue enforcing existing law; lawmakers can seek compromise on medical-care standards, reporting requirements and transparent identification. The administration’s security case deserves scrutiny against measurable outcomes, while critics’ allegations deserve testing against records rather than repetition as settled fact.
The three paths from 2027 to 2028
One path is sustained institutional conflict. Congressional committees summon DHS leaders, request operational files and dispute appropriations; the administration resists requests it considers intrusive or politically motivated. Such conflict could clarify facts, but prolonged litigation and legislative stalemate may limit immediate relief for affected families.
Another is selective negotiation. Legislators who disagree about deportation targets might nevertheless find common ground on body cameras, death reporting, credible-fear procedures, healthcare inspections or clear rules for encounters with the public. Even modest agreement would require the White House and both chambers to accept detailed, enforceable provisions. The electoral coalition itself gives no guarantee of that bargain.
A third is administrative continuity amid intensified scrutiny. Existing funding sustains operations, the president vetoes major restructuring and courts address discrete disputes as they arise. Under this path, a new Congress could alter public understanding and agency behavior without achieving the broader reforms some of its members seek.
These are institutional possibilities, not predictions. Their shape will depend on legislators’ priorities, committee assignments, executive responses, judicial decisions and public evidence yet to emerge. None should be assigned a numerical probability merely to make the analysis appear scientific.
A historic seat is not the same as a protected home
The symbolic meaning of El-Sayed’s election is substantial precisely because American citizenship, religious belonging and access to power have long been contested subjects. But symbolic representation and legal protection operate on different calendars. One changes with a ballot count; the other may depend on a detention decision made before dawn, a lawyer securing access to a client, or an officer recording a use of force.
The newly elected senators represent different constituencies and different political ideas. A Muslim senator may advocate ending ICE. A Native American senator may approach state power through the history of sovereignty and dispossession. A Black woman senator may draw on experience in law and government. A pastor from Kansas or a teacher from Texas may emphasize affordability, public accountability or negotiated enforcement. None should be presumed to speak for an entire community, and the people affected by immigration policy are neither uniformly Democratic nor uniformly opposed to deportation.
There is also a danger in imagining that the election has lifted all fears. The Washington Post reported that voting itself proceeded broadly smoothly, despite pre-election concern about federal interference. That civic success does not resolve the status of asylum seekers, undocumented workers, lawful residents confronting travel restrictions or families divided by detention.
America’s midterms produced a visible change in who holds congressional power. They did not transfer control of federal immigration agencies to the opposition party, invalidate existing statutes or repeal money already appropriated. They created oversight opportunities and raised the political cost of unchecked assertions, while leaving substantial executive discretion intact.
That is the central distinction between an electoral milestone and governing change. El-Sayed’s arrival will show that a Muslim American can win a statewide Senate contest despite attacks connected to his faith. What the next Congress does with subpoenas, nominations, appropriations and legislative negotiations will show whether a historic increase in representation produces more reliable rules for the millions of people who live under immigration law. The answer will not be found in a victory speech. It will be found in the public record of the next two years.
Discover more from The Monitor
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Opinion
Trump Announces U.S. Will Stop $4 Billion Annual Aid to Israel by End of 2026
President Donald Trump said Tuesday that the United States will end its roughly $4 billion in annual funding to Israel by the close of this year under an agreement he reached months ago with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
Speaking by phone on Fox News’ Fox & Friends as Americans voted in the midterm elections, Trump stated that the two leaders had decided to halt the payments because Israel “doesn’t need it” and to remove what he described as a damaging political talking point used by critics.
“Now, as far as paying Israel, Bibi Netanyahu and I have made a deal that we give Israel $4 billion a year, and we made a deal months ago that we’re stopping,” Trump said. “We’ve already agreed that by the end of this year we won’t be paying Israel. Now, we’ll help Israel if they need it.”
Trump added that Netanyahu had raised the idea himself, saying the Israeli leader told him it would be “appropriate” not to receive the aid given domestic political controversy in the United States. He specifically referenced criticism from Democratic Michigan Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed and others on the left, calling continued payments “a bad talking point”.
The announcement immediately raised questions about implementation. The current U.S.-Israel Memorandum of Understanding, which provides about $3.8 billion annually in military assistance, does not expire until 2028. U.S. military aid to Israel is appropriated by Congress, and experts noted that abrupt termination of ongoing programs—particularly in missile defense and counter-drone systems—would face legal and logistical hurdles. Trump has not detailed the precise mechanism or timeline for ending the funding.
There was no immediate confirmation from Netanyahu’s office or Israel’s foreign ministry. Israeli defense and financial officials were reportedly caught off guard by the public statement. The U.S. State Department did not respond to requests for comment.
The move comes amid declining American public support for unconditional aid to Israel since the war in Gaza that began in 2023. A recent Quinnipiac University poll found that nearly half of U.S. voters overall, and two-thirds of Democrats, believe the United States is too supportive of Israel. Aid to Israel has also become a point of contention within the Republican Party, drawing criticism from some isolationist and “America First” voices.
Trump framed the decision as consistent with a strong alliance, emphasising that the U.S. would continue to support Israel “if they need it” and that Israel remains a key partner. He noted that Israel could still purchase American weapons.
Analysts described the timing—on Election Day—as potentially aimed at neutralising attacks from both progressive Democrats and some within the MAGA coalition. Former Republican Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene wrote on X that the announcement was unlikely to change midterm results, while others questioned whether the pledge would hold after the election.
The development marks a significant rhetorical shift in a relationship that has included steady U.S. military financing for decades. Whether the stated cutoff materialises by the end of 2026, and in what form, remains unclear pending further details from the White House and any formal agreement with Israel.
References
Al Jazeera. (2026, November 3). Trump says US will stop giving Israel aid after year-end. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/11/3/trump-announces-that-us-will-stop-paying-israel-after-year-end
Debusmann, B., Jr. (2026, November 3). Trump says US ‘won’t be paying Israel’ by end of year. BBC News. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cmx2dlx86n9yo
Reuters. (2026, November 3). Trump says US will stop $4 billion in funding to Israel at end of 2026. https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/trump-says-us-will-stop-paying-israel-after-year-end-2026-11-03/
Times of Israel. (2026, November 3). Trump says US to end $4 billion in annual military aid to Israel by end of 2026. https://www.timesofisrael.com/trump-says-us-to-end-4-billion-in-annual-military-aid-to-israel-by-end-of-2026/
Discover more from The Monitor
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
-
Featured6 years agoThe Right-Wing Politics in United States & The Capitol Hill Mayhem
-
Conflict5 years agoKashmir Lockdown, UNGA & Thereafter
-
News5 years agoPrioritizing health & education most effective way to improve socio-economic status: President
-
Democracy5 years agoMissing You! SPSC
-
China5 years agoCoronavirus Pandemic and Global Response
-
Digital6 years agoPakistan Moves Closer to Train One Million Youth with Digital Skills
-
Canada5 years agoSocio-Economic Implications of Canadian Border Closure With U.S
-
Democracy5 years agoPresident Dr Arif Alvi Confers Civil Awards on Independence Day
